Leah Toby Roberts was born in 1976, the youngest of three children in a family living in the suburbs of Durham, North Carolina. When she was seventeen, her father was diagnosed with a chronic lung illness. This put a great deal of strain on the family as Leah began her studies at North Carolina State University in nearby Raleigh in 1995. When Leah was twenty years old and a sophomore in college, her mother died suddenly from heart disease.

In the fall of 1998, she returned to school after taking some time off, and it was also then that she had to be hospitalised after being involved in a serious car accident which resulted in a punctured lung and a shattered femur. Surgeons had to insert a metal rod next to her femur to help it heal. She told her sister Kara later that, when she saw the truck that she hit pull out in front of her, she was certain she would die and felt “born again” after her recovery. She took some time off from college. It was also then that she decided she wanted to live her life to the fullest.

In the spring of 1999, just three weeks before she was scheduled to leave for Costa Rica, her father died. Despite this, Roberts decided to continue with the field program. Since she was leaving the country and no longer had living parents, Leah granted Kara power of attorney over her bank accounts, where some money she had inherited from her parents had been deposited.

With her degree in Spanish and anthropology almost complete, Roberts dropped out of school. Kara and her brother Heath tried to persuade her to “stick it out” for six more months, but she would not change her decision. In lieu of her studies, she learned to play the guitar and took up photography as a hobby. She got a pet kitten she named Bea. She began hanging out in local coffeehouses, writing poetry about the meaning of life in her journals and making new friends in the process. With one of them, Jeannine Quiller, and with her roommate, Nicole Bennett, she discussed the idea of emulating Beat Generation novelist Jack Kerouac and going on a road trip to the West.

On the morning of March 9, 2000, Leah talked on the phone with Kara about possible future plans. They made no commitments, but Kara recalls the call ending with the understanding they would be seeing each other in some fashion in the near future. Later, in the early afternoon, Leah and Nicole agreed to do some babysitting together the next day. The roommate went out to her job and returned later, at which point she noticed that Leah’s 1993 white Jeep Cherokee was not there, nor Leah herself. She thought nothing of it as Leah had been coming and going for unpredictable intervals since she had dropped out of school and, living off her inheritance for the time being, had no need to report to a job.

However, Leah was not at the babysitting appointment the next day, and had not returned home by its end. By the end of the following day, March 11, not only was Leah still absent, but friends and family who had expected to see her had been calling the house trying to find her. On Monday, March 13, Kara reported her missing to Durham police.

The following day, Kara and Leah’s roommate Nicole searched Leah’s room. A significant amount of her clothes were missing, suggesting a planned lengthy absence. She seemed to have taken Bea with her as well, and she had left a note: “I’m not suicidal. I’m the opposite”, she reassured her sister and friends, and mentioned Kerouac. Along with the note, she had bundled some cash, approximately a month’s worth of her share of the rent and expenses, and suggested she would be returning eventually. The note was illustrated with a drawing of the Cheshire Cat’s grin.

Since Kara still had power of attorney over Leah’s bank accounts, she was able to look at her sister’s financial records. She discovered that Leah had withdrawn several thousand dollars on the afternoon of March 9, and then used her debit card to pay for a motel room near Memphis, Tennessee. Later transactions were purchases of gas or food, their locations suggesting Leah was traveling west along Interstate 40, and then north on Interstate 5 when she reached I-40’s western end in California.

After a gas purchase shortly after midnight on the morning of March 13 in Brooks, Oregon, all activity on Leah’s accounts ended. To understand why her sister was heading to the Pacific Northwest, Kara and Susie Smith, Leah’s best friend, went to the coffee shops in Durham which Leah had been frequenting. There they found Jeannine Quiller, with whom she had talked about Kerouac’s work. The two had particularly been struck by his 1958 novel The Dharma Bums, a sequel to the better-known On the Road, in which he had for a time worked as a U.S. Forest Service fire lookout on Desolation Peak in the northern Cascade Mountains of Washington, where he was profoundly affected by the beauty of the landscape. Leah had expressed interest in seeing that area for herself.

Relieved to have discovered her sister’s probable objective, Kara returned to her routine. Leah’s accounts showed no new activity, but she had no reason to believe something unfortunate had occurred.

Kara expected that Leah would call her on March 18 to wish her a happy 26th birthday. Instead, on that day, she got a note in her mailslot from the Durham County sheriff’s office, telling her to call one of their counterparts in the Whatcom County sheriff’s office in Bellingham, Washington. She then learned that, earlier that day, Leah’s Jeep had been discovered in a remote forest, but Leah herself was not present.

Early that morning in Washington, a couple jogging along Canyon Creek Road, a side route of the Mount Baker Highway that serves some isolated residences and logging camps in and around Mount Baker-Snoqualmie National Forest, a short distance south of the Canada–US border, had noticed articles of clothing at the side of the road next to a slight curve at the top of a slope. Some had been tied to the trees and branches at roadside. In the woods below, at the bottom of a steep embankment, was Leah’s Jeep, severely damaged.

From the path the car took through the trees and the extent to which both had been damaged, investigators from the Washington State Patrol determined that it had been traveling at approaching 40 miles per hour (64 km/h) when it went off the road and down the slope. The contents were tossed around inside, consistent with a multiple rollover, yet there was no blood or other signs of injury to an occupant, such as shatter marks on the glass or stretching of the seatbelt, that would probably have occurred if there had been a driver and/or passenger. It seemed possible that no one had been inside the Jeep when it crashed, suggesting the accident might have been staged or planned.

However, blankets and pillows were hung inside the windows, suggesting that it had been used as a shelter after being wrecked. Leah’s passport, checkbook, driver’s license, clothes, guitar, CDs and other belongings were found scattered in the surrounding woods. Bits of cat food and a small cat carrier were found in the vehicle, confirming that Leah had taken Bea on the trip with her, although the cat has never been found. However, valuables, such as $2,500 in cash in a pants pocket and jewelry, were also left behind, suggesting robbery had not been the reason for the accident.

Kara and Heath flew to Bellingham to assist investigators. They visited the crash site, and with the assistance of the sheriff’s office created a flyer which they posted around town. They went into businesses that Leah may have visited and queried owners and customers. Among Leah’s belongings, they found a box of mementos from the trip which provided a clue that established more clearly when Leah had arrived in Whatcom County: a ticket stub from a March 13 afternoon showing of American Beauty at the theaters in Bellingham’s Bellis Fair shopping mall. This suggested she might have spent a few hours in the city after arriving at the beginning of the day following the 5–6-hour drive from where she had bought gas in Oregon.

Near the theater was the mall’s only sit-down restaurant, where Heath and Kara believed Leah might have gone for a meal. Police were led to two customers, both men, who not only recalled Leah but had sat on each side of her at the restaurant’s counter that day, talking about Kerouac and her plans. One of the men claimed she had left with a third, whom she called Barry, and provided a description for a police sketch of the man. However, neither the other man nor any other customer who had been in the restaurant at the time could corroborate the third man’s existence.

At a police garage to which it had been towed, investigators continued to examine the Jeep, joined by the FBI, which became involved due to Leah’s having crossed state lines. Two aspects of the evidence they developed suggested to them that Leah had been the victim of a crime. First, the amount of money found in her pants suggested that she had spent very little in Bellingham, less than could be expected if she had been in the city for several days. Second, under a floor mat they found Leah’s mother’s engagement ring, which she wore constantly. Her friends in North Carolina said she treasured it for the connection it offered to her late mother and would never have taken it off voluntarily unless she had completely forgotten who she was.

Heath and Kara returned to North Carolina after four days. Working on the theory she might have been injured in the accident and wandered off, police spent two weeks in April searching, with help from dogs and helicopters, the area around where the Jeep had been found that she might reasonably be expected to cover if she had left the scene. They found no trace of her. Security camera footage from the gas station she had stopped at in Oregon showed her alone and apparently in good condition, although several times she peers out into the parking lot (an area not covered by the cameras) while waiting for her transaction to be completed. This could suggest a traveling companion, perhaps the “Barry” her dining companion at Bellis Fair claimed she had left with, but, if he was with her, investigators believe he did not travel in her car.

A few days after the Jeep was discovered, a man called the sheriff’s office to report a sighting of Leah. His wife, he claimed, had seen her, disoriented and confused, wandering around a gas station in Everett, closer to Seattle. After passing this information along, he seemed to panic and hung up before identifying himself. Police nevertheless consider the tip credible; it might have been the last sighting of Leah.

In 2001, the television series Unsolved Mysteries, then airing on Lifetime, ran a segment on the case. It generated some new tips to investigators and reports that she had been sighted elsewhere in the U.S., but nothing that proved credible.

Back in North Carolina, Kara got in touch with Monica Caison, a Wilmington woman who had helped other families find missing loved ones after cases had gone officially cold. Caison has specialized in keeping cases alive in the media, with the help of a network of volunteers called Community United Effort, after official efforts exhaust all leads. In 2005, on the fourth anniversary of Leah’s disappearance, Caison organized a caravan across the country, following Leah’s route west to Bellingham, to raise awareness about her case in particular and other unsolved missing-person cases in general; this has since become an annual event. She and Kara appeared on CNN’s Larry King Live in 2005. “I really don’t know how I would have made it through the past five years without her,” Kara told the host. “We’re just trying to, you know, keep Leah’s face out there as much as possible.”

After the initial investigation was concluded, Kara asked the Whatcom County sheriff’s office to keep Leah’s car in case more clues turned up years later. This decision bore fruit in 2006 when Mark Joseph, the detective who had originally investigated the case, passed his files on to two younger detectives. Reviewing the Leah Roberts case, one noticed that the car and its contents had not been fully processed for evidence when it was originally brought in. The two decided to finish that job.

No one had looked under the Jeep’s hood, so they pried it open and found that a wire to the starter relay had been cut. This would have allowed the car to accelerate without anyone depressing the gas pedal, confirming early suspicions that no one had been in the car when it left the road and thus had been purposely wrecked. They found a fingerprint under the hood and some male DNA on an article of Leah’s clothing.

This led them back to the man who had claimed Leah left the Bellis Fair restaurant with the third man she called “Barry”, whom only that second man had reported seeing. That man had worked as a mechanic and had a military background, further raising the detectives’ suspicions. He had also moved to Canada in the interim, complicating and lengthening an effort to get fingerprints and DNA from him. By the time that Investigation Discovery aired an episode on the case in 2011, the fingerprint had turned out not to be a match, but detectives were still waiting on the DNA sample.

As with Unsolved Mysteries, no useful tips came in as a result of the Disappeared episode. Detectives continue to hope that the additional evidence they collected will lead to a resolution of the case, although repeat searches of the area, with dogs trained to sniff for corpses and with metal detectors which could find the metal rod in Leah’s leg, have failed to discover anything new. They believe Leah most probably met with foul play and is dead, although the evidence so far supports a variety of theories about her subsequent whereabouts.

 

~Acdetective~

 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *